Persecution Watch

Tag: some

  • Forbidden Folklore – Where telling the “wrong” story carries a prison sentence.

    Forbidden Folklore – Where telling the “wrong” story carries a prison sentence.



    Forbidden Folklore – Where telling the “wrong” story carries a prison sentence

    In some countries, the power of storytelling is not just a creative expression, but a serious crime. In this article, we’ll explore the world of forbidden folklore and what happens when you tell a story that’s deemed unacceptable.

    • What is Forbidden Folklore?

    Forbidden folklore refers to stories, myths, legends, or oral traditions that are banned by governments, religious authorities, or other powerful groups. These tales often challenge the status quo, question authority, or subvert societal norms.

    • “In some cultures, telling a story that’s considered ‘wrong’ can land you in prison,” says Dr. Emily Quinn, an expert on folklore and cultural studies. “It’s not just about what you say, but also how you say it.”

    Take the example of Folkloric Fines in Spain. Until recently, the Spanish government had a system where storytellers who told “inappropriate” stories could be fined or even arrested. The fines were often substantial, with one folklorist facing a fine of €6,000 (approximately $6,700 USD) for telling a story that was deemed offensive to the Catholic Church.

    • Consequences of Forbidden Storytelling

    The consequences of being caught telling a forbidden story can be severe. In some cases, storytellers have faced imprisonment, fines, or even physical harm. The fear of punishment often leads to self-censorship and the suppression of dissenting voices.

    “As a folklorist, I’ve seen how storytelling can bring people together and inspire social change. But when you criminalize certain stories, it’s like saying that some people don’t deserve to have their voices heard,” says Dr. Quinn.

    Despite the risks, many storytellers continue to share their tales, often in secret or through coded language. This underground storytelling can be a powerful form of resistance and a way to keep cultural heritage alive.

    • Conclusion

    Forbidden folklore is a reminder that stories have the power to shape our understanding of ourselves and the world around us. When certain stories are deemed unacceptable, it’s not just a matter of free speech – it’s about silencing entire communities and cultures.

    As we navigate the complex landscape of storytelling, it’s essential to recognize the importance of preserving cultural heritage while also respecting the rights of all people to share their own tales. Whether you’re a seasoned storyteller or simply someone who loves a good yarn, remember that the power of storytelling is worth fighting for.


  • The Closed Circle – Why Some Groups Fear the Outside

    The Closed Circle – Why Some Groups Fear the Outside

    The Closed Circle: Why Some Groups Fear the Outside

    In a rapidly globalizing world, where information and ideas transcend borders at the speed of light, the persistence of closed groups can appear puzzling. Yet, for many of these communities, insularity serves as a protective mechanism against a variety of perceived threats to their cultural heritage, economic survival, and collective identity.

    Preservation of Cultural Identity

    One of the primary reasons groups may choose to remain closed off from the broader world is the desire to preserve their cultural identity. As Dr. Sarah Thompson, a cultural anthropologist at the University of Cambridge, notes, “For many communities, especially those with a rich and distinctive cultural heritage, openness can lead to a dilution of tradition.” The fear of losing language, religious practices, and traditional customs to the influences of modernity can compel communities to build proverbial walls around themselves.

    Examples of such communities include the Amish in the United States or certain indigenous tribes worldwide, who strictly regulate their interactions with outsiders. These groups have often meticulously developed guidelines that dictate the extent to which they will engage with external entities.

    Economic Survival

    Economic factors also play a significant role in why some groups opt for insulation. For groups with limited resources, opening up to external competition can pose a risk to their very livelihoods. An enclosed system can often sustain a small community more effectively than one exposed to the volatility of global markets. As highlighted in an article from The Economist, small-scale economies often thrive in isolation where the balance of supply and demand remains relatively stable.

    Collective Security

    Security concerns, whether physical, social, or psychological, also contribute to the fear of the outside for many groups. Outsiders can be perceived as threats that bring potential violence, criminal activity, or social unrest. This sentiment is expressed by historical precedent, where invasions and colonization have left indelible marks on the collective memories of societies.

    “Closed societies often emerge from the scars of historical traumas, seeking solace in what’s familiar while warding off what’s unknown,” says Jonathan Arliss, a historian specializing in post-colonial studies.

    The View from Inside

    While from an outsider’s perspective, such insularity can seem like fear or paranoia, it often stems from a rational evaluation of potential threats. The decision to remain closed is frequently a strategic one—born from centuries of evolving experiences and challenges. Understanding the dynamics of these decisions requires a sensitive and respectful examination of each community’s unique history and values.

    In the end, open dialogue, mutual respect, and measured engagement may pave the way for bridging divides, allowing closed communities to experience the benefits of outside interaction without sacrificing their core values.